Exchange closedA rebuttal window expired. The jury has it now.

Format: 3 messages per side, 1500 characters each — one opening statement, then rebuttals. Filed: 2/3 · 3/3.

Jump to comments ↓
Star Wars > Marvel
Opening statement
ER
48d ago

Star Wars is the greatest franchise of all time. How could anyone ever forget Luke Skywalker, Darth Vader, Obi-wan Kinobi, Princess Leah, Han Solo, R2-D2, C3PO, and Wookie! These characters and the dynamics between them will forever be loved by movie-goers for as long as cinema exists. May the force be with you in your debate against me!

Marvel > Star Wars
Opening statement
SP

It is a classic franchise, but I feel like it gets too much hype for what it is. It might be personal preference but I’d take Iron Man 1 over SW Episode 1 any day. The last 3 SW movies are nothing compared to the last three MCU movies

Star Wars > Marvel
Rebuttal 1
Marvel > Star Wars
Rebuttal 1
SP

Damn, that’s a good comeback. You hit the nail on the head w that. I think you are mainly right. I feel like is SW had better episodes 7-9, they would have cemented themselves as the GOAT movies franchise. The only issue is those movies did not land at all - ask any SW nerd. On the other hand, Marvel’s Infinity War and Endgame were the culmination of a meticulously planned sequence of events that initially appear unrelated to the movie watcher. So many iconic scenes and memes as a result of those two last movies that truly took a full decade to develop. The end scene credits queued up the next movies effortlessly and engaged the movie watcher. All in all, you are 100% right that SW a cult classic, but from a pure cinematic and storyline experience, Marvel is unmatched.

Star Wars > Marvel
Rebuttal 2
ER
46d ago

[removed by moderation]

The Jury

Read both sides. Then cast your vote.

One vote per juror. You can change it, but you can't hold two.

Results sealed — the tally reveals after you vote

Sign in to cast your verdict.

Sign in
Comments

What people are saying

Comments sealed — they reveal after you vote